Frankfurt changed the debate on free will and moral responsibility with his hypothetical intervening demon. Frankfurt cases the principle of alternate possibilities. However, harry frankfurt in his famous paper alternate possibilities and moral responsibility challenges freedom condition for moral. Frankfurt also states that, practically no one, however, seems inclined to deny or even to question that the principle of alter. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility ucl. The problem of alternate possibilities and moral responsibility is one that philosophers continue to pursue, and understanding this issue is important for understanding our moral assessments of people and their actions. In an influential article, harry frankfurt 1969 dubbed this. Philosopherssuchasrobert kane,davidwiderker,carlginet,keithwyma,stewartgoetz,derkpere. The principle of alternate possibilities as sufficient but not. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility by sam.
There might be some other reason for which determinism undercuts our ordinary moral practices. This paper will relate these questions to the argument initiated by harry frankfurt that alternative possibilities are not required for moral responsibility, and to john martin fischer and mark ravizzas extension of that argument in terms of guidance control in a. A theoretical argument against the principle of alternate. I do not know of any decisive arguments employing frankfurttype examples for the conclusion that only guidance control, and not regulative control, is required for moral responsibility. Harry frankfurt argues against the principle of alternate. Frankfurt cases also known as frankfurt counterexamples or frankfurt style cases were presented by philosopher harry frankfurt in 1969 as counterexamples to the principle of alternate possibilities pap, which holds that an agent is morally responsible for an action only if that person could have done otherwise. Frankfurt, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility john martin fischer, responsiveness and moral responsibility harry g. I think that the principle of alternative possibilities is mistakenly defined and that most of frankfurt s analysis is chasing a red herring.
Pdf on the signpost principle of alternate possibilities. Sep 22, 2014 the problem of alternate possibilities and moral responsibility is one that philosophers continue to pursue, and understanding this issue is important for understanding our moral assessments of people and their actions. Suppose that john is on his way to a voting booth and is undecided about whether to vote for. For example, john martin fischers semicompatibilism assumes with frankfurt that we can have moral responsibility, even if determinism and or indeterminism are incompatible with free will. Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities. Frankfurt s case doesnt quite show this much, if it succeeds. Pdf frankfurt alternate possibilities and moral responsibility. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility paper. Abstract in his seminal paper alternate possibilities and moral responsibility.
Moya and others published moral responsibility without alternative possibilities. Moral responsibility, freedom, and alternate possibilities by uncg. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility by harry. In an influential paper, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility 1969, the american philosopher harry frankfurt questioned whether the ability to do otherwise is truly necessary for freedom. Frankfurt alternative possibilities and moral responsibility here is an in. The near necessity of alternate possibilities for moral. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility free will and morality van inwagen. Frankfurt presents as an example of moral responsibility without alternate possibilities might rather be thought of directly as an example of free will.
There is a moral principle that states, according to philosopher harry frankfurt, that a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise frankfurt 829. Weekly discussion moral responsibility and alternative. Frankfurt on ought implies can and alternative possibilities. Are alternate possibilities required for moral responsibility. A person is morally responsible for what he has done only if.
Frankfurt alternative possibilities and moral responsibility. Intuitions about free will and moral responsibility. Frankfurts thesis the principle of alternate possibilities pap that a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise. Apr 21, 2006 since then, frankfurt s thesis has been at the center of philosophical discussions on free will and moral responsibility. Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities, edited by david widerker and michael mckenna, draws together the most recent work on frankfurt s thesis by leading theorists in the area of free will and responsibility. Frankfurt denies the claim that one cannot be morally responsible if one lacks freedom to do otherwise. Frankfurt princeton university abstract this essay challenges the widely accepted principle that a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise. The starting point for this debate is harry frankfurt s now classic 1969 paper, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility, which is duly reprinted here. In his classic paper, the principle of alternate possibilities, harry frankfurt presented counterexamples to the principle named in his title. Frankfurt, freedom of the will and the concept of a person. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility 829 approached this subject with medieval language and modern skill. He believes a person is morally responsible for what he has done, only if he could have done otherwise.
Frankfurt alternate possibilities and moral responsibility handout. He is professor emeritus of philosophy at princeton university, where he taught from 1990 until 2002, and previously taught at yale university, rockefeller university, and ohio state university. May 17, 2006 the debates about whether alternative possibilities are required for moral responsibility have issued in what some might consider stalemates. Choice, moral responsibility and alternative possibilities.
Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility paper by. Harry frankfurt, however, in his famous paper titled. Essays on moral responsibility and alternative possibilities. Harry gordon frankfurt born may 29, 1929 is an american philosopher. Mar 14, 2012 are alternate possibilities required for moral responsibility. C if determinism is true, then we do not act freely. P2 if determinism is true, then we could not have acted otherwise. Since then, frankfurt s thesis has been at the center of philosophical discussions on free will and moral responsibility. In frankfurts original formulation, that principle is 1pap a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise.
Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility harry g. Frankfurts case doesnt quite show this much, if it succeeds. Moral responsibility alternate possibilities and moral responsibility 1969 learn with flashcards, games, and more for free. The principle of alternate possibilities is the principle where a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise. Investigation of frankfurts argument on moral responsibility. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility word. In alternate possibilities and moral responsibility, harry frankfurt attempts to falsify the principle of alternate possibilities. So responsibility and alternative possibilities go together after all, and pap would remain true moral responsibility requires alternative possibilities when free choices are not determined. Moral responsibility, freedom, and alternate possibilities.
Frankfurt sketches a kind of scenario which has come to be called a frankfurt style case. A person may well be morally responsible for what he has done even though he could not have done otherwise. Frankfurts principle of alternative possibilities and moral responsibility states that, a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise frankfurt 159. Strictly, it only shows that determinism wouldnt undercut our moral practices because determinism rules out alternate possibilities. Libertarianism and the philosophical significance of frankfurt scenarios find. We would, of course, consistent with the position taken on war. Undoubtedly, frankfurt s reasoning besides outcome reasoning changed compatibilism discussion in a decisive manner because. But im not sure that it does the work frankfurt wants it to do.
Sep 29, 2007 frankfurt himself, having argued in 1969 against the incompatibilists premise linking responsibility with alternate possibilities, has sought to defend an account according to which we might be free and responsible no matter whether we have alternate possibilities. Harry frankfurt describes the principle of alternate possibilities pap as follows. It seems as though frankfurt realized that on the conventional picture of moral responsibility, his account of free will characterized an overly high number of people as not morally responsible, and so he threw in this argument to remedy that. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility mit.
P1 you act freely only if you could have acted otherwise. Frankfurt, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility. In harry frankfurts philosophy journal on personhood and moral responsibility he formulates many ideas of how people should act. The principle of alternate possibilities pap states that moral responsibility requires indeterminism, or multiple possible futures. Ethics handout 24 harry frankfurt, alternate possibilities. Frankfurt convincingly shows that moral responsibility does not require alternative possibilities in fact, but i think that moral responsibility does require alternative possibilities in belief. And does choice imply alternative possibilities of some significant sort. The requirement of alternative possibilities for moral.
Pdf moral responsibility without alternative possibilities. Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities 1st edition. As the majority of the essays appear here for the first time, moral responsibility and alternative possibilities offers the. Free will moral responsibility possibility frankfurt, h.